Thursday, September 29, 2011

Book Review: PIRATE OF MY HEART by Jamie Carie

You may not know this about me, but I am a complete nut for All Things Pirate. When I see the word "pirate" anywhere -- especially on the cover of a book -- I pause for a second look. The cover of Jamie Carie's latest novel certainly gave me pause. So I got the book, planning to use it in conjunction with my National Talk Like a Pirate Day post, and... didn't.

I read the novel in plenty of time to complete a review for the September 19th "holiday" post, but... the book contained very little actual pirate action and seemed entirely inappropriate for the occasion. The hero? Not a pirate. The heroine? Also, not a pirate.

So... where are the bloomin' pirates????

Well, they are in there, but... not as prevalent as I'd hoped.

I'd expected a swashbuckling adventure on the high seas -- a moving, edgy, and romantically well-crafted tale from an author whose work I have dearly loved reading in the past. But avast, me hearties! I must admit: I was doomed to be disappointed. There was barely any swashbuckling to speak of -- and the pirates that did appear were much less charismatic than the legends would have us believe.


I'm not proud of it, but I judged this book by it's piratical title and cover art. I expected dashing rogues and adventure and... well... more pirates! But, alas... I should have read the back cover copy. That is, after all, what it's there for.

(from the Barnes & Noble product description)
(and, very likely, the back cover, too. But I wouldn't know.)

When her doting father dies, Lady Kendra Townsend is given a choice: marry the horrid man of her cold, money-grubbing uncle's choosing or leave England to risk a new life in America with unknown relatives. Armed with the faith that God has a plan for her, Kendra boards a cargo ship and meets American sea captain Dorian Colburn. But the captain has been wounded by a woman before and guards his independent life. A swashbuckling man doesn't need an English heiress to make him slow down, feel again, or be challenged with questions about his faith-or so he thinks. It is not until Dorian must save Kendra from the dark forces surrounding her that he decides she may be worth the risk.

So: it wasn't the genuine pirate adventure I'd hoped for, but it was a sweet and light historical romance that I was still able (though disappointed) to enjoy. Even though I did appreciate the romance of the story, I had a few problems with some of the wine and cheese moments* along the way.

1. The heroine was somewhat brave, but not all that daring; so when she was daring, I wasn't quite sure I believed it.

2. Additionally, there was a serious flood of the word "smolder" -- in several derivatives -- in reference to a gaze, a look, his eyes, etc. (It made me cringe-- and giggle a bit -- thinking of Eugene from Disney's Tangled saying, "Here comes the smolder.")

3. And finally, the ending was very... tidy. A little too conveniently tidy for my taste. But I suppose that is somewhat subjective.

But, my pirate-fetish disappointment aside, this was an enjoyable romance to read, even with a few spare helpings of wine and cheese.

I have read several of Jamie Carie's previous novels and have been wowed by her storyweaving craft. That being said, I did not feel this particular novel was quite up to the standard of quality and originality I've come to expect from such a talented author. But -- and there is that persistent BUT again -- it was an enjoyable light romance -- a perfect lazy-weekend read. As long as you're not expecting a jolt of Captain Jack Sparrow (or, better yet, Will Turner!) I would readily recommend this novel.

If you're in the mood for a pleasingly sweet, light romance, pick up Pirate of My Heart by Jamie Carie and pass the afternoon with Captain Dorian and Lady Kendra.

Serena's Rating:


  1. Great, honest review, Joy! I was disappointed in this one too. I mean, that cover!! Amazing!! I thought everything happened really abruptly.

  2. Thankfully I wasn't too terribly disappointed in this as I had read someone else's review before I read it. Their complaint was the same as yours, that there were no pirate moments. So I went in expecting very little swashbuckling moments. BUT, I too have read other Jamie Carie books and found them much better than this one. Pleasant though it was, I have liked others better. Great review!

  3. Carrie: "abrupt" is a good word...

    Julie: Yes, it was pleasant -- I agree. But...

    Thanks for stopping by, ladies!

  4. Serena,

    This review sheds new light on your Talk Like a Pirate Day post. I had no idea it was such an important holiday for you. LOL.

    But bummer about this one's lack of Capt. Jack. :(

    Thanks for the review!

  5. Oh your review was like jelly on toast...;D You make the book sound so sweet.....anything with pirates kicks butt..

  6. Thank you very much for this review. I've been eyeing this book for a while and planning on purchasing it, thinking it would be full of pirate fun and romance. I was also judging it by its pretty, nautical cover. Thanks again for the real scoop.

  7. I’ll never ever miss the chance to read your new blogs. Glittering work guys!!


I love comments more than Starbucks! Thanks for leaving one!


Related Posts with Thumbnails