Thursday, September 29, 2011

Book Review: PIRATE OF MY HEART by Jamie Carie

You may not know this about me, but I am a complete nut for All Things Pirate. When I see the word "pirate" anywhere -- especially on the cover of a book -- I pause for a second look. The cover of Jamie Carie's latest novel certainly gave me pause. So I got the book, planning to use it in conjunction with my National Talk Like a Pirate Day post, and... didn't.

I read the novel in plenty of time to complete a review for the September 19th "holiday" post, but... the book contained very little actual pirate action and seemed entirely inappropriate for the occasion. The hero? Not a pirate. The heroine? Also, not a pirate.

So... where are the bloomin' pirates????

Well, they are in there, but... not as prevalent as I'd hoped.

I'd expected a swashbuckling adventure on the high seas -- a moving, edgy, and romantically well-crafted tale from an author whose work I have dearly loved reading in the past. But avast, me hearties! I must admit: I was doomed to be disappointed. There was barely any swashbuckling to speak of -- and the pirates that did appear were much less charismatic than the legends would have us believe.

Aarrrgh.

I'm not proud of it, but I judged this book by it's piratical title and cover art. I expected dashing rogues and adventure and... well... more pirates! But, alas... I should have read the back cover copy. That is, after all, what it's there for.

THE SITCH:
(from the Barnes & Noble product description)
(and, very likely, the back cover, too. But I wouldn't know.)

When her doting father dies, Lady Kendra Townsend is given a choice: marry the horrid man of her cold, money-grubbing uncle's choosing or leave England to risk a new life in America with unknown relatives. Armed with the faith that God has a plan for her, Kendra boards a cargo ship and meets American sea captain Dorian Colburn. But the captain has been wounded by a woman before and guards his independent life. A swashbuckling man doesn't need an English heiress to make him slow down, feel again, or be challenged with questions about his faith-or so he thinks. It is not until Dorian must save Kendra from the dark forces surrounding her that he decides she may be worth the risk.

So: it wasn't the genuine pirate adventure I'd hoped for, but it was a sweet and light historical romance that I was still able (though disappointed) to enjoy. Even though I did appreciate the romance of the story, I had a few problems with some of the wine and cheese moments* along the way.


1. The heroine was somewhat brave, but not all that daring; so when she was daring, I wasn't quite sure I believed it.

2. Additionally, there was a serious flood of the word "smolder" -- in several derivatives -- in reference to a gaze, a look, his eyes, etc. (It made me cringe-- and giggle a bit -- thinking of Eugene from Disney's Tangled saying, "Here comes the smolder.")

3. And finally, the ending was very... tidy. A little too conveniently tidy for my taste. But I suppose that is somewhat subjective.

But, my pirate-fetish disappointment aside, this was an enjoyable romance to read, even with a few spare helpings of wine and cheese.

I have read several of Jamie Carie's previous novels and have been wowed by her storyweaving craft. That being said, I did not feel this particular novel was quite up to the standard of quality and originality I've come to expect from such a talented author. But -- and there is that persistent BUT again -- it was an enjoyable light romance -- a perfect lazy-weekend read. As long as you're not expecting a jolt of Captain Jack Sparrow (or, better yet, Will Turner!) I would readily recommend this novel.

If you're in the mood for a pleasingly sweet, light romance, pick up Pirate of My Heart by Jamie Carie and pass the afternoon with Captain Dorian and Lady Kendra.

Serena's Rating:








7 comments:

  1. Great, honest review, Joy! I was disappointed in this one too. I mean, that cover!! Amazing!! I thought everything happened really abruptly.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thankfully I wasn't too terribly disappointed in this as I had read someone else's review before I read it. Their complaint was the same as yours, that there were no pirate moments. So I went in expecting very little swashbuckling moments. BUT, I too have read other Jamie Carie books and found them much better than this one. Pleasant though it was, I have liked others better. Great review!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Carrie: "abrupt" is a good word...

    Julie: Yes, it was pleasant -- I agree. But...

    Thanks for stopping by, ladies!
    ~Serena

    ReplyDelete
  4. Serena,

    This review sheds new light on your Talk Like a Pirate Day post. I had no idea it was such an important holiday for you. LOL.

    But bummer about this one's lack of Capt. Jack. :(

    Thanks for the review!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Oh your review was like jelly on toast...;D You make the book sound so sweet.....anything with pirates kicks butt..

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you very much for this review. I've been eyeing this book for a while and planning on purchasing it, thinking it would be full of pirate fun and romance. I was also judging it by its pretty, nautical cover. Thanks again for the real scoop.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I’ll never ever miss the chance to read your new blogs. Glittering work guys!!

    ReplyDelete

I love comments more than Starbucks! Thanks for leaving one!

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails